YayBlogger.com
BLOGGER TEMPLATES

Friday, March 7, 2014

N2008: It is not acceptable that multinational companies often exercise more power than national governments. How far do you agree or disagree?

N2008: It is not acceptable that multinational companies often exercise more power than national governments. How far do you agree or disagree?

Keywords: 

  • 'often' - not absolute 
  • multinational companies - serve private interests 
  • national governments - aim to serve public interests 

Multinational companies can exercise more power than national governments through various means. Particularly, multinational companies can significantly influence governmental decisions due to the high dependence of the governments on these multinational governments' funding and support, especially in capitalist and democratic societies. This may result in conflicting interests between these two stakeholders and the general public in the society, since multinational companies largely serve private interests while national governments aim to serve public interests. If multinational companies exercise more power than national governments, thus, personal economic benefits may be weighed heavier against the welfare of the national population in general. More often than not, we see a degree of cronyism in national governments to a fault and this can potentially result in corporate penetration of the government, which can in turn cause corruption and inefficient resource allocation to take place. I therefore agree that it is largely not acceptable for multinational companies to often exercise more power than national governments. Multinational companies and national governments should instead enjoy a balanced power system where they can influence each other's decision making while harbouring similar amounts of power. 

1. Fundamentally, multinational companies exercise more power than national governments because of their boundless potential influence which can be extended across political boundaries into regional and international economies. Governments, however, can only exercise their power within their political boundaries and any infringement on other nations can yield back-lashing and condemnation of the nation's actions and reputations.

"Governments are powerful within their own territory, though they have to operate within constitutional arrangements and comply with broadly accepted international norms. If they don't, they pay a price – revolution and/or poverty for their people. Outside their jurisdiction, however, they are not that powerful at all, and the smaller the country the less power it has."

"Businesses are powerful because they employ people and governments are desperate for jobs. They also get things done. No government, however competent, can build an aircraft or develop an oil field. "

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/comment/hamish-mcrae/hamish-mcrae-power-balance-shifts-to-the-private-sector-and-away-from-governments-8723023.html


2. Multinational companies may exercise more power than national governments when they harness immense economic influence in the nation's employment, investments and technology progression. The national government therefore has to give in to these companies' demands in exchange for the mentioned derived benefits and this may cause direct conflict with the national population's welfare. 

  • environmental sacrifice which places a downward pressure on nearby residents' living welfare

    e.g. Lynas plant in Malaysia
    http://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/feb/26/malaysians-protest-rare-earth-refinery 
    "Authorities recently granted Lynas a licence to operate the rare earth plant in Pahang state, the first outside China in years, and it has been the subject of heated protests over health and environmental risks posed by potential leaks of radioactive waste."

    "Lynas says its refinery could meet nearly a third of world demand for rare earths, excluding China. It also may curtail China's stranglehold on the global supply of 17 rare earths essential for making hi-tech goods, including flat-screen TVs, mobile phones, hybrid cars and weapons." 

3a. If multinational companies exercise greater power than national governments, this can make the governments run the risk of corporate penetration of the government. These companies can potentially exert excessive influence and access to governments' confidential information and decisions, which can put the nations' defense, economy and bilateral relations in jeopardy due to the exchange of intelligence with other governments obtained by the multinational companies. 


  •  Loss of confidential intelligence and governmental control by the national government
    e.g. Royal Dutch Shell's infiltration of the Nigerian government to gain control of fiscal decision making and intelligence 

    http://www.theguardian.com/business/2010/dec/08/wikileaks-cables-shell-nigeria-spying

    "Royal Dutch Shell has people in "all the relevant ministries" in the Nigerian government and has access to "everything being done in those ministries," according to leaked diplomatic cables published by WikiLeaks and posted on the website of the British newspaper The Guardian on Thursday."

3b. There may be controversial governmental policy resultant from the want to conform to multinational companies' pressure by national governments if multinational companies exercise greater power than national governments. 

  • e.g. Invasion of Iraq by the US/UK in 2003
    Infringement of Iraq's sovereignty driven by motivations for Iraq's vast oil capacity 




    "In 2000, Big Oil, including Exxon, Chevron, BP and Shell, spent more money to get fellow oilmen Bush and Cheney into office than they had spent on any previous election. Just over a week into Bush's first term, their efforts paid off when the National Energy Policy Development Group, chaired by Cheney, was formed, bringing the administration and the oil companies together to plot our collective energy future. In March, the task force 
    reviewed lists and maps outlining Iraq's entire oil productive capacity."

    http://edition.cnn.com/2013/03/19/opinion/iraq-war-oil-juhasz/


    ***




    "The interests of private companies in the marketisation of Iraq's oil were a significant factor in the decision to go to war. Several US politicians stood to personally gain from the invasion of Iraq, through their involvements with corporations who stood to gain contracts once the Iraqi market was prised open. For example, US Vice-President Dick Cheney was CEO of Halliburton until 2000. He was still being paid by the company in 2003, when it was awarded nearly a billion dollars-worth of contracts to work with US troops. British companies also stood to gain lucrative contracts in post-war Iraq."


4. Multinational companies and national governments should instead aim to strike a power balance where a consensus between the nation population and the multinational companies is reached with effective compromise from both sides. 



No comments:

Post a Comment