Does a presence of a foreign
power ever help a country with problems? (2008)
![]() |
| Foreign aid: Who is benefiting? |
Keywords:
1. Foreign Powers – International organizations like UN
or great powers like USA or use of other countries’ military forces - Outside intervention
in the intrastate conflict or other issues
2. Presence – Direct or indirect intervention
3. Helped – Resolving the problems / Successful in
achieving the objectives
4. Country with problems – Types of problems ( Economic,
political or social)
Introduction:
1. Reasons why foreign powers always tend to intervene in
other countries’ affairs and the motives behind trying to help these countries
to resolve some of their most pressing issues.
2. Some examples of common foreign powers’ interventions
over the last few decades
3. Define the problems countries are facing that require
foreign intervention -Countries with social unrest and political upheavals/
environmental issues/ economic recession like UK and Australia in 2007 to 2009
4. Usually are they successful? Yes, successful to a
large extent as they often were able to meet the objectives they set before
embarking on this mission.
Over the decades, we face many foreign policies around the world and very often, we question the rights of these foreign powers in intervening in other nations' affairs, be it politically or even economically. We usually recognize the United Nations as one most important inter-governmental organization that uphold the justice and bring security to the international communities.However, is it true that only the United Nations Security Council has the legal right and power to enforce international laws and meddle with other nations' affairs? Unfortunately, the answer is no because it is in fact no power to go against the five permanent members of UN also known as the Great Powers today if they choose to exercise their exclusive vetoes. This could have been one of the flaws of UN that many scholars have been arguing against. Yet, it is an undeniable fact that more often than not, foreign powers such as the United States of America can provide the right and adequate amount of financial, humanitarian or even military aid that usually can effectively help to eradicate or reduce the impacts of the specific problems that are plaguing the countries. Thus, they are relatively significant in helping these affected nations to eliminate some of the most pressing issues to ease the tensions and worries of the people, thus maintaining social stability at the same time. Although there were a number of failed interventions that instead aggravated the appalling situations in the affected nations, the foreign powers were still able to at least meet some of their mission objectives. Hence, presence of the right foreign powers usually can help countries with problems.
Over the decades, we face many foreign policies around the world and very often, we question the rights of these foreign powers in intervening in other nations' affairs, be it politically or even economically. We usually recognize the United Nations as one most important inter-governmental organization that uphold the justice and bring security to the international communities.However, is it true that only the United Nations Security Council has the legal right and power to enforce international laws and meddle with other nations' affairs? Unfortunately, the answer is no because it is in fact no power to go against the five permanent members of UN also known as the Great Powers today if they choose to exercise their exclusive vetoes. This could have been one of the flaws of UN that many scholars have been arguing against. Yet, it is an undeniable fact that more often than not, foreign powers such as the United States of America can provide the right and adequate amount of financial, humanitarian or even military aid that usually can effectively help to eradicate or reduce the impacts of the specific problems that are plaguing the countries. Thus, they are relatively significant in helping these affected nations to eliminate some of the most pressing issues to ease the tensions and worries of the people, thus maintaining social stability at the same time. Although there were a number of failed interventions that instead aggravated the appalling situations in the affected nations, the foreign powers were still able to at least meet some of their mission objectives. Hence, presence of the right foreign powers usually can help countries with problems.
Body:
- 1. The presence of
foreign powers such as the international organizations is able to provide relatively
swift and efficient aid to resolve some of the most pressing humanitarian
issues within a country that is adversely affected by natural disasters. They
help the LDCs especially to minimize the impacts of natural disasters.
Example: On
January 2010, an earthquake of major proportions in Haiti resulted in thousands
of buildings collapsed, more than 200 thousand people killed, 300 thousand
injured and about one and half million people displaced.
The country was under United Nations (UN) mandate on behalf of the peacekeeping. The military command of MINUSTAH, the position of Brazil, sought to provide initial relief and at the same time maintaining safe conditions.
Meanwhile, the willingness of governments and international organizations and NGOs led to the influx of people, materials, equipment and humanitarian aid in general in amounts above the manageability of those who took control of the shares in the country operation established since 2004 named UN Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), and the military command was from Brazil.
Thus, the three main actors who acted in the phases of the response and recovery immediately after the earthquake were the Government of Haiti (GoH), MINUSTAH and the U.S. Joint Task Force – Haiti (JTF-H). During the actions undertaken by MINUSTAH and U.S. forces there was the concern to strengthen the government, coordinating the activities and priorities, in order to demonstrate that GoH has the capability to assist the population.
The country was under United Nations (UN) mandate on behalf of the peacekeeping. The military command of MINUSTAH, the position of Brazil, sought to provide initial relief and at the same time maintaining safe conditions.
Meanwhile, the willingness of governments and international organizations and NGOs led to the influx of people, materials, equipment and humanitarian aid in general in amounts above the manageability of those who took control of the shares in the country operation established since 2004 named UN Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), and the military command was from Brazil.
Thus, the three main actors who acted in the phases of the response and recovery immediately after the earthquake were the Government of Haiti (GoH), MINUSTAH and the U.S. Joint Task Force – Haiti (JTF-H). During the actions undertaken by MINUSTAH and U.S. forces there was the concern to strengthen the government, coordinating the activities and priorities, in order to demonstrate that GoH has the capability to assist the population.
- 2. Sometimes, the
presence of foreign powers help to bring political intervention to a country to help raise greater awareness
for human rights among the citizens. This empowers the people to stand up
against corrupted and inefficient governments and thus push for the right
political leadership to propel prosperity for their country.
Example: The 2003 US-Iraq war backs to the 1990 Persian Gulf War. By the time the ceasefire with Iran was signed in August 1988, Iraq was bankrupt and heavily indebted to Saudi Arabia and Kuwait. In 1990, Iraq invades Kuwait on the base that the country was producing too much oil; therefore undercutting the value of Iraq’s oil supply.
Within days, the United Nations (UN) imposes economic sanctions on Iraq for attempting to annex Kuwait. Many UNSC resolutions were passed regarding the conflict; one of the most important was Resolution 678, passed on November 29, 1990 giving Iraq a withdrawal deadline of January 15, 1991 and authorizing “all necessary means to uphold and implement Resolution 660” which is a diplomatic expression authorizing the use of force.
The justifications to the Gulf War were as follows:
Iraqi violation of Kuwaiti territorial integrity
The support of long-time ally, Saudi Arabia, who is a key supplier of oil and has a geopolitical importance,
Example: The 2003 US-Iraq war backs to the 1990 Persian Gulf War. By the time the ceasefire with Iran was signed in August 1988, Iraq was bankrupt and heavily indebted to Saudi Arabia and Kuwait. In 1990, Iraq invades Kuwait on the base that the country was producing too much oil; therefore undercutting the value of Iraq’s oil supply.
Within days, the United Nations (UN) imposes economic sanctions on Iraq for attempting to annex Kuwait. Many UNSC resolutions were passed regarding the conflict; one of the most important was Resolution 678, passed on November 29, 1990 giving Iraq a withdrawal deadline of January 15, 1991 and authorizing “all necessary means to uphold and implement Resolution 660” which is a diplomatic expression authorizing the use of force.
The justifications to the Gulf War were as follows:
Iraqi violation of Kuwaiti territorial integrity
The support of long-time ally, Saudi Arabia, who is a key supplier of oil and has a geopolitical importance,
Human rights abuses under President Saddam Hussein who
possessed chemical weapons (it is said that he had previously used against his
own people and against Iranian troops in the Iran-Iraq war) and biological
weapons and was known to be attempting to build atomic bombs.
On May 1, 2003 President Bush (US intervention) declared the “end of major combat operations” in Iraq. Coalition forces remain in Iraq under a UNSC mandate, helping to provide security and to support the freely elected government.
Following the invasion, the United States established the Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA) to govern Iraq. CPA transferred full governmental authority on 30 June 2004 to the Iraqi Interim Government.
The elections in Iraq were held on January 2005 whereby President is Jalal Talabani, Vice Presidents are Adil Abd Al-Mahdi and Tariq al-Hashimi and Prime Minister is Nuri al-Maliki. Besides, Iraq’s permanent constitution was approved on 15 October 2005 with a constitutional referendum where more than 63% of eligible Iraqis came out across the country to vote and it passed with a 78% overall majority - The US helped Iraq to establish democratic elections so that the people can gain back their most fundamental rights to choose the government whom they want to lead the country.
On May 1, 2003 President Bush (US intervention) declared the “end of major combat operations” in Iraq. Coalition forces remain in Iraq under a UNSC mandate, helping to provide security and to support the freely elected government.
Following the invasion, the United States established the Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA) to govern Iraq. CPA transferred full governmental authority on 30 June 2004 to the Iraqi Interim Government.
The elections in Iraq were held on January 2005 whereby President is Jalal Talabani, Vice Presidents are Adil Abd Al-Mahdi and Tariq al-Hashimi and Prime Minister is Nuri al-Maliki. Besides, Iraq’s permanent constitution was approved on 15 October 2005 with a constitutional referendum where more than 63% of eligible Iraqis came out across the country to vote and it passed with a 78% overall majority - The US helped Iraq to establish democratic elections so that the people can gain back their most fundamental rights to choose the government whom they want to lead the country.
3.The presence of several international economic organizations
have helped many countries to relinquish from economic crisis as well as
providing some of the fast-growing economies with more opportunities to steer
their economy towards having sustainable growth.
Example: Since the war on terrorism began in 2001 and
the Millennium Challenge Account and Global HIV initiative were launched in
2004, the US has increased foreign aid spending dramatically in some regions,
including East and South Asia. The US has raised military, economic and
development assistance with Pakistan, India, the Philippines and Indonesia
receiving the bulk of the increases. Taiwan and Singapore, two newly developed
countries in East Asia, also received US assistance. Taiwan receives over
$550,000 annually to develop its export control system and combat trafficking
in persons. Singapore was provided with
roughly $700,000 per year to help country to stimulate higher quality exports,
deter, detect and interdict the flow of illegal arms across its maritime
borders.
Pakistan's bilateral relations with China:
Economic trade between Pakistan and China is increasing at a rapid pace and a free trade agreement has recently been signed. Military and technological transactions continue to dominate the economic relationship between the two nations, although in recent years China has pledged to vastly increase their investment in Pakistan's economy and infrastructure. Among other things, China has been helping to develop Pakistan's infrastructure through the building of power plants, roads and communication nodes.
Pak-China Economic Corridor is under construction. It will connect Pakistan with China and the Central Asian countries with highway connecting Kashgar to Khunjrab and .Gwadar. Gwadar port in southern Pakistan will serve as the trade nerve center for China, as most of its trade especially that of oil will be done through the port, which is already controlled by Beijing. (China wanted to have close bilateral relations with Pakistan because it is militarily powerful and help China to indirectly balances her power in the region.)
Pakistan's bilateral relations with China:
Economic trade between Pakistan and China is increasing at a rapid pace and a free trade agreement has recently been signed. Military and technological transactions continue to dominate the economic relationship between the two nations, although in recent years China has pledged to vastly increase their investment in Pakistan's economy and infrastructure. Among other things, China has been helping to develop Pakistan's infrastructure through the building of power plants, roads and communication nodes.
Pak-China Economic Corridor is under construction. It will connect Pakistan with China and the Central Asian countries with highway connecting Kashgar to Khunjrab and .Gwadar. Gwadar port in southern Pakistan will serve as the trade nerve center for China, as most of its trade especially that of oil will be done through the port, which is already controlled by Beijing. (China wanted to have close bilateral relations with Pakistan because it is militarily powerful and help China to indirectly balances her power in the region.)
- 4. However, sometimes, foreign intervention in political affairs of a
country usually complicates the situation as it may be perceived ad
infringement of national sovereignty. Thus, the intervention may backfired and
instead of resolving some of the problems, it hardline the problems and make it
more difficult to be resolved between the parties.
Examples: A
complicated US-Russia game in Syria
Secretary
of State John Kerry testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington, Tuesday, Sept. 3,
2013, before a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing to advance President
Barack Obama's request for congressional authorization for military
intervention in Syria. And a strong rebuttal to
remarks by Assad, Kerry said there is very compelling evidence that the Syrian
regime used chemical weapons against his own people.
In an interview by Charlie Rose, slated to air Monday
on CBS "This Morning," Assad argued that the evidence Kerry has
disclosed about chemical weapons use amounts to a "big lie" that
resembles the case for war in Iraq that then-Secretary of State Colin Powell
made to the United Nations over a decade ago. The issue of using chemical
weapons for destruction was worsened by the presence of two great powers –US
and USSR and thus, attempts to resolution are hindered and tensions are still
high between the parties.
Conclusion
Usually, foreign
powers that intervened in a country plagued with serious problems possess the
capability to provide significant amount of both financial and humanitarian aid
to help resolve the problems. Thus, they may be successful in minimizing the
impacts of the problems but are unable to entirely resolve the problems.

No comments:
Post a Comment